Canada, known for its robust immigration policies and welcoming stance towards newcomers, offers a beacon of hope for thousands seeking a new beginning. For the year 2022, Canada welcomed 437,180 immigrants and saw a net increase of the number of non-permanent residents estimated at 607,782. However, within Canada’s Immigrant Tax Challenge, the financial landscape, especially concerning payroll taxes, presents unforeseen challenges for many immigrants. This complexity underscores the need for a nuanced understanding and support to navigate the fiscal responsibilities that come with a new life in Canada.
The focus on immigration tends to obscure the opposite trend: emigration. Some studies report the especially high likelihood of immigrants to emigrate from Canada. While some immigrants may have planned to leave Canada at some point, emigration may also attest to the difficulties many immigrants encounter in integrating into the Canadian labour market or society.
Understanding Payroll Taxes in Canada
Payroll taxes in Canada are contributions collected by employers from employees’ wages and salaries for social programs like the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Employment Insurance (EI). These mandatory deductions are designed to provide a safety net for Canadians, covering pension benefits and support during periods of unemployment. However, for newcomers, who are often in the initial stages of setting down roots and managing settlement expenses, these deductions can significantly reduce their disposable income.
The Canada Pension Plan (CPP)
CPP is a social insurance plan that is funded by the contributions of employees, employers and self-employed people as well as the revenue earned on CPP investments. The CPP covers virtually all employed and self-employed people in Canada, excluding Quebec, which operates its own comprehensive plan, the Quebec Pension Plan. The CPP is the second pillar of Canada’s retirement income system, which also includes the Old Age Security and the Guaranteed Income Supplement (the first pillar) and private savings (the third pillar). The CPP provides income replacement to contributors and their families in the event of retirement, disability or death. The CPP is a statutory program that is governed by the federal government and the provinces. It is enabled by the CPP legislation. Eligibility criteria must be met in order to receive benefits.
The Québec Pension Plan (QPP)
QPP is a compulsory public insurance plan for workers aged 18 and over whose annual employment income is greater than $3500. Its purpose is to provide persons who have worked in Québec and their families with basic financial protection in the event of retirement, death or disability. Elsewhere in Canada, the equivalent plan is the Canada Pension Plan.
The Employment Insurance (EI)
EI program provides temporary income support to unemployed workers while they look for employment or to upgrade their skills. The EI program also provides special benefits to workers who take time off work due to specific life events:
- illness
- pregnancy
- caring for a newborn or newly adopted child
- caring for a critically ill or injured person
- caring for a family member who is seriously ill with a significant risk of death
Income tax calculator Canada
Calculate your income tax in Canada
The Newcomer’s Challenge
Newcomers to Canada may be:
- Permanent residents (including people who have received “approval-in-principle” from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada to stay in Canada)
- refugees (protected persons)
- temporary residents (including student, worker, or temporary resident permit holders)
- The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) considers you a newcomer to Canada for the first year you are a resident of Canada.
You become a resident of Canada for income tax purposes when you have enough residential ties in Canada. You usually establish residential ties on the day you arrive in Canada.
Newcomers to Canada face a myriad of challenges, from cultural adaptation to employment. Payroll taxes add another layer of complexity to their financial adjustment. Unlike Canadian citizens who may be familiar with the tax system, immigrants might not fully understand the implications of these deductions on their earnings. The lack of targeted deductions or tax breaks for newcomers exacerbates this issue, potentially hindering their ability to save and invest in their new life in Canada.
Case Study: The Patel Family
Consider the hypothetical case of the Patel family, who immigrated to Canada from India. Despite securing employment shortly after their arrival, they were surprised by the significant portion of their income deducted for CPP and EI contributions. With limited initial knowledge about Canada’s tax system, they found themselves unprepared for the impact on their finances, struggling to meet their immediate living expenses and delaying important long-term investments in their family’s future.
International Comparisons and Best Practices
Looking globally, countries like Australia and the United Kingdom have implemented tax systems with provisions specifically designed to support newcomers’ transition. These include tax credits and allowances in the initial years of residency, acknowledging the unique financial challenges immigrants face. Such comparative examples underscore the potential for Canada to enhance its support for newcomers through the tax system.
Towards a More Inclusive Approach
Advocacy groups and policymakers have recognized the need for a more inclusive approach to payroll taxes for newcomers. Suggestions include introducing a grace period during which lower payroll deductions are applied, offering financial literacy programs tailored to immigrants, and providing informational resources in multiple languages to improve accessibility and understanding of the tax system.
As Canada continues to welcome newcomers, it is imperative to address the financial challenges they face, including the impact of payroll taxes. By adopting measures to ease this burden, Canada can ensure a smoother transition for immigrants, supporting their journey towards becoming integral, contributing members of Canadian society. This not only benefits the newcomers but enriches the Canadian fabric with diverse perspectives and experiences.